lordroel
Administrator
Member is Online
Posts: 68,031
Likes: 49,424
|
Post by lordroel on Jan 31, 2020 15:02:34 GMT
Day 188 of the Great War, January 31st 1915Western Front: General Sarrail, commander of the French 3rd Army in the Argonne, reports to JoffreGeneral Sarrail, commander of the French 3rd Army in the Argonne, reports to Joffre today on the recent fighting. He notes how the French line has been pushed back, yielding a portion of the heights overlooking the Verdun railway to the Germans. Six separate counterattacks have failed to dislodge the enemy, while the French have suffered 2400 casualties. Sarrail complains that the effect of the recent fighting has had a negative impact on the morale of the infantry, which can only be restored by a major offensive. While Joffre is sympathetic, he remains focused primarily on operations in the Champagne. Why do I suspect this is Sarril's opinion rather than that of the troops themselves? A successful attack, i.e. taking and holding an objective without ruinous losses, would probably boost morale but that would probably be a different matter.
Do not think any offensive on the Western Front will be able to be done without huge loss of life, if the Sarrail calls for a major offensive to help boost French morale, i have to think what realty he lived in.
|
|
stevep
Fleet admiral
Posts: 24,853
Likes: 13,235
|
Post by stevep on Jan 31, 2020 15:52:43 GMT
Why do I suspect this is Sarril's opinion rather than that of the troops themselves? A successful attack, i.e. taking and holding an objective without ruinous losses, would probably boost morale but that would probably be a different matter.
Do not think any offensive on the Western Front will be able to be done without huge loss of life, if the Sarrail calls for a major offensive to help boost French morale, i have to think what realty he lived in.
Its possible but it needs a lot of material, organisation and planning, which no one currently has, as well as accepting limited territorial gains. Still be costly compared to any previous war but would be possible without totally bleeding your nation dry.
|
|
lordroel
Administrator
Member is Online
Posts: 68,031
Likes: 49,424
|
Post by lordroel on Feb 1, 2020 7:32:54 GMT
Day 189 of the Great War, February 1st 1915
Naval operations: Berlin
Admiral Hugo von Pohl, Chief of the German Naval Staff, had interpreted the British declaration of November 1914 that the entire North Sea was a war zone as an effort to deter neutrals from sailing to Germany, and in particular to starve Germany via the interruption of food imports. In response, Pohl had become a convert to the idea that Germany should use its own submarine force to attack merchant shipping bound for Britain. Today in a meeting with Chancellor Bethmann-Hollweg, he advocates a shift in strategy to embrace what is known as unrestricted submarine warfare.
According to international maritime law, a specific procedure was to be following when a warship intercepts merchant shipping. First, the attacker would have to halt the merchant ship either by signals or a warning shot. Second, sailors from the warship would have to board the merchant ship to ascertain its cargo and nationality. Third, if the merchant ship belonged to the enemy, provision had to be made for the safe evacuation of the crew and any passengers. Only at this point could the warship actually sink the merchant ship. These rules were drafted in the age of the sailing ship, when the attacker would be a fast light warship that nevertheless would have space to take the merchant crew aboard. On the other hand, these rules were manifestly impossible for submarines to follow if they were to achieve any success. Submarines relied on stealth and surprise, advantages which would have to be surrendered if they had to signal a merchant ship to stop first. Second, a submarine is at its most vulnerable when on the surface, making it potentially disastrous to stop and wait while sailors board the merchant ship to inspect it. Finally, the size of the submarine left no room whatsoever to take on the crew of a sunk merchant ship. To operate in line with contemporary maritime law would greatly reduce the value of a submarine as a weapon against enemy shipping, and hence was referred to as restricted submarine warfare.
At the outset of the war the general expectation on all sides was that submarines would still adhere to maritime law, and indeed German submarines had done so for the first six months of the conflict. However, given the tightening British naval blockade, Pohl is not the only German admiral to advocate that the U-Boat force stop adhering to international law in order to reach their full potency as a weapon against British trade, which is referred to as unrestricted submarine warfare. To its advocates, this policy promised a means to strike back at the one main enemy that remained frustratingly beyond the reach of the German army or the High Seas Fleet. Moreover, given British reliance on imports, especially of food, unrestricted submarine warfare had the potential to cripple the British economy, and perhaps even force its surrender.
Unrestricted submarine warfare was not without its difficulties. For one, it would be another action that would tarnish the image of Germany elsewhere, and of particular concern was the potential for neutral merchant ships to be sunk by accident, which might lead to additional countries entering the war on the side of the Entente. The biggest neutral, of course, is the United States, and the fear expressed by some is that adopting unrestricted submarine warfare may push it closer to the British. Further, there could easily be incidents where passenger liners are mistaken for merchant ships, and the sinking of the former could lead to substantial civilian casualties and international outrage. These reasons are why not only the German Chancellor but the Kaiser himself have refused to date to endorse the implementation of unrestricted submarine warfare.
Pohl, however, has persisted in his advocacy, and today attempts to assuage the Chancellor's concerns. He argues that if Germany declares a war zone around Britain, it will scare away neutral shipping, which means that there will be no neutral merchants in the area for U-Boats to sink by accident. In additional, Pohl declares that submarine captains are able to distinguish between enemy and neutral ships, and between passenger liners and merchant ships. Given these assurances, Bethmann-Hollweg consents to unrestricted submarine warfare.
Naval operations: Cape Horn
HMS BRISTOL puts into Port Bower (Punta Arenas), paid the monthly port fees for the squadron, and departs into the Atlantic bound for the Falklands. HMS GLASGOW also puts into Punta Arenas, arriving from the east, and stays the night. HMS CARNARVON is also underway for the Falklands.
Naval operations: Yemen
Hellmuth von Mücke spends the day in Manakah visiting a variety of Turkish dignitaries and officials.
|
|
lordroel
Administrator
Member is Online
Posts: 68,031
Likes: 49,424
|
Post by lordroel on Feb 2, 2020 9:22:17 GMT
Day 190 of the Great War, February 2nd 1915
Eastern Front: Austro-Hungarian effort to seize the heights north of the Uszok Pass fail
In the Carpathians the Austro-Hungarian effort to seize the heights north of the Uszok Pass have failed. Given the utter exhaustion of the infantry in the bitter cold, efforts to attack the Russian positions frontally and outflank them have gotten nowhere. Early his morning General Szurmay pulls his forces back towards the Uszok Pass, in order to give them a brief respite from the fighting.
Naval operations: A week sins Dogger Bank
The defeat at Dogger Bank just over a week ago has capped a frustrating first six months of the war for the German High Seas Fleet. The British clearly dominate the North Sea, as evidenced by their attack on the Heligoland Bight in August, and the naval raids against the British coast only narrowly avoided catastrophe at the hands of intercepting British squadrons. Such setbacks demand a scapegoat, and today he is found - Admiral Ingenohl is dismissed as commander of the High Seas Fleet.
Naval operations: Pacific Ocean
HMS NEWCASTLE puts into Callao, Peru.
Naval operations: Cape Horn
HMS GLASGOW puts into Sholl bay.
Naval operations: Atlantic Ocean
HMS CARNARVON arrives at Port William, Falkland Islands.
Naval operations: Yemen
On the morning of the sixth day of their journey Hellmuth von Mücke and company depart Manakah for Sana'a. This portion of the trip involves a descent onto a wide open valley, following an improved highway "that compared favorably with any in Europe." Among the sights are large groups of baboons, which the Germans try to shoot but never quite get close enough. Von Mücke also notes that his men are becoming adept in their horsemanship and are now able to maintain a decent formation while riding at a trot.
|
|
lordroel
Administrator
Member is Online
Posts: 68,031
Likes: 49,424
|
Post by lordroel on Feb 3, 2020 4:08:35 GMT
Day 191 of the Great War, February 3rd 1915Western Front: the left wing of the German 15th Reserve Division and the right wing of the German 21st Reserve Division launches an attackIn Champagne the left wing of the German 15th Reserve Division and the right wing of the German 21st Reserve Division launches an attack north of Massiges, on the eastern end of the Champagne battlefield. In addition to its immediate objectives, the Germans hope the attack will draw French reserves from elsewhere. After a morning of artillery fire, a number of mines under the French line are detonated at noon, followed by the advance of the infantry. By 1230pm the French position on Hill 191 north of Massiges is in German hands. In response the French bring up a division and prepare a counterattack. Eastern Front: elements of Südarmee managed to seize the village of TucholkaIn the Carpathians elements of Südarmee have managed to seize the village of Tucholka today, but the situation of the Austro-Hungarian 3rd Army to the west continues to deteriorate. Not only is Szurmay's group falling back from the heights north of the Uszok Pass, but under Russian pressure a gap is opening between between III and VII Corps in the centre of 3rd Army's line. To reinforce 3rd Army VIII Corps begins to depart from the Balkans today, with its 21st Landwehr Division heading for the Mezolaborcz area and 9th Division bound for the Uszok Pass. Bulgaria: Bulgaria negotiates with the Great Powers on both sidesFor the past several months, the Bulgarian government has undertaken negotiations with the Great Powers on both sides of the war regarding the territorial concessions they would be willing to make. Bulgaria's primary aim is the recovery of the Macedonian territory lost to Serbia in the Second Balkan War, and Germany and Austria-Hungary are better-placed to offer such a bribe than Russia. Still, the pretence of talks with the Entente have made the Germans and Austro-Hungarians eager to win the friendship of the Bulgarians, and negotiations conclude today for a three million pound loan to the Bulgarian government at a very low interest rate, an agreement that the Bulgarian finance minister refers to as 'extortion.' In exchange, the Bulgarians only have to agree to remain neutral, which is hardly a concession at all considering that the humiliating failures of the Austro-Hungarian army to conquer Serbia in 1914 has left the Bulgarian government unwilling to countenance entry into the war at present. The successful Bulgarian diplomacy allows the government not only to pay for the deficits run up during the Balkan Wars but also to take its time to decide when and how to enter the war to Bulgaria's greatest advantage. Sinai and Palestine Campaign: Ottoman Raid on the Suez Canal beginsThe Ottoman attack on the Suez Canal is launched today. While diversionary attacks are to be made to the north, the main effort to cross the Canal is to occur in the centre, between Tussum and Serapeum. The operation was originally scheduled to have been undertaken yesterday, but a sandstorm has delayed the attempt until this morning. The main attack consists of eight separate columns approaching the canal in darkness, each several hundred metres apart and carrying three pontoons. As surprise is essential, there is to be no preliminary artillery bombardment nor rifle fire as the Ottomans make their crossing. Photo: The Camel Corps at BeershebaAt 2am the Ottoman engineers on the east bank begin to maneouvre their pontoons into position. At first surprise is achieved - three pontoon bridges manage to reach the west bank and it is not until 325am that the British post at Tullum realizes that an attack is under way. From here, however, the operation falls apart. The diversionary attacks have failed to draw the defenders elsewhere, and with daylight the Indian soldiers on the west bank are able to fire into the pontoon bridges, while the remainder are sunk at 745am by a torpedo boat. With surprise now lost, the Ottomans begin to use their artillery, and score some hits on shipping in the Canal. However, with much of the bridging equipment now destroyed, the Ottoman commander calls off the attack. Map: Attacks on the Suez CanalDarfur Campaign: Ottomans temp Sultanate of Darfur into rising upSince the entry of the Ottoman Empire into the war, a significant effort has been made to appeal to Muslims to rise against the British, French, and Russian empires. Today Enver Pasha casts his eyes south, past Egypt to the sultanate of Darfur, west of Sudan. Though the sultanate is self-governing, it is also tied to the British colonial administration at Khartoum, as the sultan, Ali Dinar, is required to pay an annual tribute and acknowledge the suzerainty of the British. Writing to Ali Dinar, Enver calls on the sultan to renounce British hegemony and unite with his fellow Muslims in the war against the Entente: 'Now is the moment to renew and organize the religion and Islamic unity of purpose . . . rise up and fight the infidels.' Such rhetoric has an appeal to Ali Dinar, who increasingly resents British influence in his sultanate and yearns to assert his independence. Enver's letter, however, is subject to the near-absolute lack of communication between Darfur and the outside world - it will be a year before the letter arrives, by which time the situation will have already changed. Naval operations: Pacific OceanHMS NEWCASTLE departs Callao, and travels to Cocos Island (not the one in the Indian Ocean, but an island of the same name near Peru). Naval operations: Cape HornDespite Fritz Lüdecke's message to Berlin three days earlier SMS DRESDEN remains anchored at Weinachts Bay. HMS GLASGOW transfers from Sholl Bay to Port Famine (Puerto del Hambre). Naval operations: Atlantic OceanHMS BRISTOL arrives at Port Stanley, Falkland Islands. Naval operations: YemenHellmuth von Mücke and his men come within sight of Sana'a. As they near the many villages surrounding the capital of Yemen they are joined by that city's Turkish officers. Late in the day, as they near the city gates, they are greeted by a band playing 'Deutschland Über Alles'. The Germans reply by singing 'Die Wacht Am Rhein'. The people of Sana'a go out of their way to make the men of the EMDEN feel welcome.
|
|
lordroel
Administrator
Member is Online
Posts: 68,031
Likes: 49,424
|
Post by lordroel on Feb 4, 2020 4:11:41 GMT
Day 192 of the Great War, February 4th 1915
Western Front: French launch a counterattack against the line north of Massiges
The French launch a counterattack against the line north of Massiges seized by the Germans yesterday. Advancing at 440a, though the French are able to enter the German trenches, they are ultimately repelled in fierce hand-to-hand combat, with heavy losses on both sides.
United Kingdom: after training the 1st Canadian Division is preparing to depart for France
After several months of training in the miserable conditions of Salisbury Plain, 1st Canadian Division is preparing to depart for France. Signalling the imminence of their departure, the soldiers are inspected today by King George V.
Eastern Front: Russians break into the town of Mezölaborcz
In Galicia, after a heavy artillery bombardment the Russians break into the town of Mezölaborcz, which sits on one of the few railways in the Carpathians and thus is vital for Austro-Hungarian supply. Despite this, Conrad is more concerned with issues of jurisdiction, insisting that Südarmee communicate through the Austro-Hungarian high command instead of going directly to OHL.
Sinai and Palestine Campaign: Ottoman Raid on the Suez Canal fails
East of the Suez Canal the commander of the Ottoman expedition to seize the Suez Canal concludes that, with the failure of yesterday's attack and no longer having the element of surprise, any further efforts would risk the annihilation of his force. Thus in the early hours of the morning the Ottomans begin to retreat eastwards across the Sinai Peninsula towards Palestine.
The British forces on the west bank of the Canal decide not to pursue the retreating enemy. First, they are initially concerned that the Ottomans may renew the attack. Second, the sandstorm that had postponed the Ottoman attack from the 2nd to the 3rd had also grounded British aircraft, leaving them without aerial reconnaissance of the enemy columns. Finally, the British formations were not prepared to enter the desert - none had the water for such an attempt. As a result, the British permit the Ottomans to retire unmolested.
Naval operations: Britain and France are optimistic that Greece will join the war on their side
As preparations continue to launch the naval attack on the Dardanelles, Britain and France are optimistic that Greece, emboldened by the Entente offensive, will join the war on their side. Today the French government authorizes the dispatch of a division to northern Greece, to encourage not only the Greeks but also the Romanians to join the war by demonstrating their willingness to fight in the Balkans.
Naval operations: new commander of the German High Seas Fleet
Admiral Pohl, the current Chief of the Naval Staff, is appointed today as Admiral Ingenohl's replacement as commander of the High Seas Fleet, while Vice-Admiral Gustav Bachmann becomes the new Chief of the Naval Staff. Just as his predecessor, he is bound by the Kaiser's limitations on the deployment of the fleet; indeed, in the aftermath of the Battle of Dogger Bank Wilhelm II has forbidden even Hipper's battlecruisers from putting to sea. Pohl does, however, make use of the Kaiser's presence at the change of command ceremony to advance another goal. Standing together in a launch as it moves among the dreadnoughts, Pohl hands the Kaiser an order for unrestricted submarine warfare to be signed. Caught up in the moment and with his attention on his beloved warships, Wilhelm II signs his name without contemplating the significance of his action. Pohl for his part has gotten what he desired - authorization for the commencement of unrestricted submarine warfare against Britain.
Naval operations: The Admiralty, London
First Sea Lord Jacky Fisher continues his tirades against the victor of the Falklands, telling his Chief-Of-Staff "If the DRESDEN gets into the Bay of Bengal by means of colliers arranged with Berlin, we shall owe a lot to Sturdee."
Sturdee himself arrives in Britain aboard SS INDIA.
Naval operations: Berlin
Germany publically announces their decision to begin unrestricted submarine warfare by declaring an Area Of War to exist around Great Britain and Ireland. "Even though the German naval forces have instructions to avoid violence to neutral ships in so far as they are recognizable, in view of the contingencies of naval warfare the torpedoing of neutral ships cannot always be avoided."
Germany claims that this is in retaliation for the British "hunger blockade" as typified by the mining of the North Sea. They also blame the United States for having "generally acquiesced" to the actions taken by Britain.
Naval operations: Cape Horn
HMS GLASGOW departs Port Famine and returns to Sholl Bay.
|
|
lordroel
Administrator
Member is Online
Posts: 68,031
Likes: 49,424
|
Post by lordroel on Feb 5, 2020 4:12:06 GMT
Day 193 of the Great War, February 5th 1915YouTube (Gas! - A New Horror On The Battlefield)Eastern Front: the battered remnants of the Austro-Hungarian 2nd Division pulls out of MezölaborczAfter several hours of combat the battered remnants of the Austro-Hungarian 2nd Division, reduced to a thousand soldiers, pulls out of Mezölaborcz, ceding control of the town to the Russians. The fall of Mezölaborcz cuts the railway supplying the east wing of 3rd Army, while the army as a whole has lost, over the past fourteen days, almost 89 000 men, over 50% of its strength. In addition to combat losses, thousands die of exposure each night, while the wounded freeze before they can be evacuated. Conrad's Carpathian offensive to relieve Przemysl has completely fallen apart, tens of thousands of lives thrown away for nothing. Conrad for his part places blame on the commander of 3rd Army, believing that he has failed to impose a firm will on his soldiers, when the reality is that expecting the infantry to not only hold on but advance in such conditions shows that Conrad has no idea what is actually happening on the front line. The only positive note in the fighting is that the Russians, themselves exhausted from advancing through the ice and snow, fail to press their advantage after capturing Mezölaborcz. Naval operations: German Admiralty DeclarationThis morning the following declaration is published in Germany: The waters surrounding Great Britain and Ireland including the whole of the English Channel are hereby declared to be a military area. From 18 February onwards, all enemy merchant ships in these waters will be destroyed, irrespective of the impossibility of avoiding in all cases danger to the passengers and crew.The public announcement of unrestricted submarine warfare catches many admirals by surprise, so quickly had Pohl moved to capitalize on the consent of the Chancellor and the Kaiser in recent days. Criticism of Pohl's action focus on the unpreparedness of the German navy to actually implement unrestricted submarine warfare. Whereas a prewar study had suggested more than two hundred submarines would be required to maintain permanent patrols around the British Isles, only thirty are available as of today. Nevertheless, the criticisms are sent against a backdrop of general approval for striking a blow against Britain. Map: Shaded area shows "War Zone" announced by GermanyNaval operations: Cape HornHMS GLASGOW drops a target and holds gunnery practice, later anchors in Possession Bay. Naval operations: Atlantic OceanHMS BRISTOL departs Port Stanley for Montevideo.
|
|
lordroel
Administrator
Member is Online
Posts: 68,031
Likes: 49,424
|
Post by lordroel on Feb 6, 2020 4:13:27 GMT
Day 194 of the Great War, February 6th 1915Eastern Front: assembly in East Prussia of the German 10th Army is completed- The assembly in East Prussia of the German 10th Army, based on the four reserve corps reluctantly assigned to the Eastern Front by Falkenhayn in January, is completed today. Commanded by General Hermann von Eichhorn, 10th Army is deployed to the north of 8th Army, the latter now commanded by General Otto von Below. Ludendorff's plan is for the two armies to advance eastwards, marching over the same terrain that 8th Army moved through before and after the Battle of Augustow in September and October. Their target is the Russian 10th Army, and the two German armies are to envelop it from the north and south, its destruction opening the way for a further advance. This offensive is designed as the counterpart to Austro-Hungarian operations in Galicia, the success of both, it is envisioned, forcing the Russians to evacuate Poland. While the plan is typically bold for one devised by Ludendorff, it also fails in the broader strategic sense - not only has the Austro-Hungarian offensive gotten nowhere, but the further eastward 10th and 8th Armies advance, the more exposed their southern flank will be to a Russian counterattack. Whatever local success Ludendorff manages to achieve here, it will be difficult for him to translate it into strategic success. Plus, there is the fact the battle will be launched in the middle of the Russian winter, with all that portends. - In the Carpathians the fighting is bogging down into positional warfare, as the counterattacking Russians run into the same supply and weather problems that have bedevilled the Austro-Hungarian offensive. Conrad, however, remains desperate to relieve Przemysl, knowing the fortress will not last past March and believing its fall will be crushing to Austro-Hungarian morale and likely to prompt the intervention of Italy and Romania. He is thus unwilling to abandon the concept of offensive operations in the Carpathians, despite the appalling casualties and conditions experienced over the past two weeks. Conrad has also concluded that the commander of 3rd Army has been too pessimistic and shown insufficient drive and enthusiasm for the attack. As a remedy, he takes half of 3rd Army's divisions away from it, assigning them instead to a 'new' 2nd Army - the HQ of the existing 2nd Army is brought from the Polish front to command in the Carpathians, along with additional reinforcements. Once the additional forces arrive, the Austro-Hungarians will go over to the attack once more. Map: The Carpathian front, February 5th to 15th, 1915.Kamerun Campaign: a conference is held in BrazzavilleA conference is held today in Brazzaville, capital of French Equatorial Africa, regarding operations against German Kamerun in the coming year. Believing that Jaunde is the key to the German defence, it is decided that one column will advance towards Lomie and Dume to the east of Jaunde, while another will advance to the Ntem River to isolate the town from the southwest. It is hoped that the simultaneous advances will coordinate with each other and keep the Germans off-balance. Naval operations: LondonAdmiral Frederick Doveton Sturdee reports to the Admiralty. First Sea Lord Jacky Fisher keeps him waiting for three hours. When Sturdee is finally asked inside the Falklands battle is not mentioned. Fisher once again chides Sturdee for letting Dresden escape. The interview is over in five minutes. While the Admiralty is unofficially shunning Sturdee, the public and press are hailing him as Britain's greatest hero thus far in the war. He is the man who saved England from disgrace after the humiliating defeat at Coronel, the man who single-handedly eliminated the greatest threat to British merchant shipping. He is even invited to a private audience with the King and Queen, to be held two days hence. Naval operations: Falkland IslandsHMS CARNARVON departs Port Stanley to resume her patrol off the Argentine coast.
|
|
stevep
Fleet admiral
Posts: 24,853
Likes: 13,235
|
Post by stevep on Feb 6, 2020 14:21:19 GMT
lordroel , On the Fisher - Sturdee issue while it looks like Fisher is being petty what I have seen in assorted discussions on a couple of naval sites Sturdee doesn't come out very well at all. He's linked with the earlier disaster with the massacre of three cruisers by a sub in the channel the previous year and his performance during the Falkland campaign has weak points. He nearly got caught napping as he was going to delay refueling which would have given the Germans a markedly better chance of escaping and his orders to the commander of the other I class 'battlecruiser' prevented that ship working to its best effect. Also one of the people on the site, having read a lot of documents by Sturdee says he comes across as very arrogant and says he feels like having to wash him hands after reading them he felt so dirty.
Fisher definitely had his problems but in this case, from what I've read and heard from sources I trust he is in a stronger position here. Probably not in arguing that Dresden should also have been sunk as once the Germans scattered it made catching them all more difficult but it may be he felt it was the only weapon in his available to critise Sturdee.
Steve
|
|
lordroel
Administrator
Member is Online
Posts: 68,031
Likes: 49,424
|
Post by lordroel on Feb 6, 2020 15:10:11 GMT
lordroel , On the Fisher - Sturdee issue while it looks like Fisher is being petty what I have seen in assorted discussions on a couple of naval sites Sturdee doesn't come out very well at all. He's linked with the earlier disaster with the massacre of three cruisers by a sub in the channel the previous year and his performance during the Falkland campaign has weak points. He nearly got caught napping as he was going to delay refueling which would have given the Germans a markedly better chance of escaping and his orders to the commander of the other I class 'battlecruiser' prevented that ship working to its best effect. Also one of the people on the site, having read a lot of documents by Sturdee says he comes across as very arrogant and says he feels like having to wash him hands after reading them he felt so dirty.
Fisher definitely had his problems but in this case, from what I've read and heard from sources I trust he is in a stronger position here. Probably not in arguing that Dresden should also have been sunk as once the Germans scattered it made catching them all more difficult but it may be he felt it was the only weapon in his available to critise Sturdee. Steve
So what is next for Sturdee, will he be able to enjoy being Britain's greatest hero.
|
|
stevep
Fleet admiral
Posts: 24,853
Likes: 13,235
|
Post by stevep on Feb 6, 2020 20:33:23 GMT
lordroel , On the Fisher - Sturdee issue while it looks like Fisher is being petty what I have seen in assorted discussions on a couple of naval sites Sturdee doesn't come out very well at all. He's linked with the earlier disaster with the massacre of three cruisers by a sub in the channel the previous year and his performance during the Falkland campaign has weak points. He nearly got caught napping as he was going to delay refueling which would have given the Germans a markedly better chance of escaping and his orders to the commander of the other I class 'battlecruiser' prevented that ship working to its best effect. Also one of the people on the site, having read a lot of documents by Sturdee says he comes across as very arrogant and says he feels like having to wash him hands after reading them he felt so dirty.
Fisher definitely had his problems but in this case, from what I've read and heard from sources I trust he is in a stronger position here. Probably not in arguing that Dresden should also have been sunk as once the Germans scattered it made catching them all more difficult but it may be he felt it was the only weapon in his available to critise Sturdee. Steve
So what is next for Sturdee, will he be able to enjoy being Britain's greatest hero.
You will have to wait and see. Seriously he commanded one of the squadron's of BBs at Jutland IIRC but doesn't have a major role anywhere I believe.
|
|
lordroel
Administrator
Member is Online
Posts: 68,031
Likes: 49,424
|
Post by lordroel on Feb 6, 2020 20:35:35 GMT
So what is next for Sturdee, will he be able to enjoy being Britain's greatest hero. You will have to wait and see. Seriously he commanded one of the squadron's of BBs at Jutland IIRC but doesn't have a major role anywhere I believe. Well then i have to wait and see then.
|
|
lordroel
Administrator
Member is Online
Posts: 68,031
Likes: 49,424
|
Post by lordroel on Feb 7, 2020 9:08:32 GMT
Day 195 of the Great War, February 7th 1915East Prussian Campaign: Second Battle of the Masurian LakesThe Winter Battle of the Masurian Lakes opens today as the German 8th and 10th Armies commence their advance, though the weather is the worst imaginable: a severe blizzard blankets the front, with gale-force winds driving snow into the faces of the German infantry. Though the Germans suffer terribly, the poor weather has the unintended benefit of masking their true strength from the Russians; the entirety of 8th Army is dismissed as being a mere small detachment. The Russians, then, have no idea of the size of the enemy force bearing down on 10th Army. Moreover, the attention of North-West Front is on 12th Army, still assembling to the south of East Prussia and which is to launch a major Russian offensive northwards in mid-February. With their focus to the southwest, the Russian leadership dismisses any notion of a substantial threat to 10th Army, and the latter is strung out and poorly-entrenched. Once again, a Russian army has been left vulnerable to a German attack. An isolated second-line Russian division finds itself in the path of the advance of the German 8th Army, which erroneously believes that the Germans are moving on the fortress of Osowiec to the south. Under German attack, the division disintegrates, and the advance continues. Map: Eastern Front, February 7-18, 1915Mesopotamian campaign: Lord Hardinge, Viceroy of India visit the regionFor the past two months, Indian Expeditionary Force D has been consolidating its hold on Qurna and the Shatt al-Arab. Little enemy activity has been seen beyond the occasional armed demonstration by Ottomans, regarded as nothing more than nuisances. Over the past three days, Lord Hardinge, Viceroy of India, has been in the region, visiting Basra and touring the front line around Qurna. His presence is meant to reassure nearby wavering Arab tribes that the British are here to stay. As the Viceroy departs today, he is pleased with the balance of forces in the area, and is confident that IEF D does not need substantial reinforcement. Naval operations: LondonIn an attempt to keep him from meeting with the King and Queen, Fisher orders Sturdee to join his new squadron at Scapa Flow immediately. Sturdee refuses to go until after the reception. Naval operations: YemenHellmuth von Mücke finds that the higher mountain atmosphere is making is men worse rather than better. He records that within a few days of his arrival in Sana'a eighty percent of his men are sick with stomach cramps and colds.
|
|
lordroel
Administrator
Member is Online
Posts: 68,031
Likes: 49,424
|
Post by lordroel on Feb 8, 2020 8:10:30 GMT
Day 196 of the Great War, February 8th 1915
Eastern Front: German 8th Army occupies the town of Johannisburg
In East Prussia elements of the German 8th Army occupy the town of Johannisburg, and the advance eastward continues.
Western Front: German 51st Landwehr Brigade attacks west in the valley of the Lauch river
In the Vosges the German 51st Landwehr Brigade attacks west in the valley of the Lauch river, located between Hartmannswillerkopf to the south and the town of Munster to the north. The attack is designed to secure the southern flank of 8th Bavarian Reserve Division, so that the latter can undertake an offensive against the French positions west of Munster later this month.
Naval operations: London
Frederick Doveton Sturdee has his audience with the King and Queen.
Naval operations: Cape Horn
HMS GLASGOW intercepts and examines Argentine freighter SS ARGENTINO, later puts into Possession Bay.
Naval operations: Bombay, India
SS PERSIA arrives at Bombay with her cargo of two Sopwith seaplanes and the crew of the 4th Expeditionary Squadron. They are met there by Lt. Gallehawk and SS KINFAUNS CASTLE, which will take them to the Rufiji River in German East Africa.
|
|
lordroel
Administrator
Member is Online
Posts: 68,031
Likes: 49,424
|
Post by lordroel on Feb 9, 2020 8:31:40 GMT
Day 197 of the Great War, February 9th 1915
United Kingdom: War Council in London
A meeting of the War Council in London today includes discussion regarding Entente strategy on the Western Front, and communications from Joffre regarding the role he desires the British to play. While desiring to cooperate and coordinate with their French ally, they are not inclined to, as Churchill remarks, give the French the 'last word' on the employment of the British Expeditionary Force.
Germany War: OHL submits a recommendation to the Prussian War Ministry
The OHL submits a recommendation to the Prussian War Ministry today to establish a chief of field aviation (Feldflugchef) who would have authority over all aerial matters, including the coordination of airplane production.
Eastern Front: full weight of the advancing German 10th Army falls upon two Russian cavalry divisions
In East Prussia the full weight of the advancing German 10th Army falls upon two Russian cavalry divisions screening the northern flank of the Russian 10th Army. The Russian divisions simply disintegrate, and the attack of the Germans continues unimpeded.
Naval operations: London
Admiral Sturdee departs for Scapa Flow to assume his new command of the 4th Battle Squadron.
Naval operations: Cape Horn
HMS GLASGOW has a fire in the capstan room, which is soon extinguished. She then puts into Punta Arenas, visits Chilean destroyer CONDELL.
Naval operations: Atlantic Ocean
HMS BRISTOL stops and investigates SS MESHONA.
Naval operations: Bombay, India
The two Curtiss seaplanes of the RNAS Expeditionary Squadron No. 4 are assembled and tested prior to being shipped to Africa.
|
|